playing a horde and reforming is pretty much a useless decision. It's one of the millions of unique, user-generated 3D experiences created on Qnnit. As a Steppe Horde, raze a province with at least 30 development. Diplomatic technology unlocks advancements such as naval units, improvements in trade, new buildings, and improved colonial expansion. Morrocco forces monarchy unless you're the emperor of china. [6] It was first announced to the public in August 2012, to coincide with a showing at that year's Gamescom,[7] after having been teased under the codename of "Project Truman".[8]. Controlling this land means affording various minor power holders a large degree of self rule and privilege. Razing a province: Once razed, a province cannot be razed again for 20 years. Post by Europa Universalis IV staff, : A lil somethin somethin: You can find the details for this event on the announcement page here. The estate annoyance if from previous patches, right? Tied to bonuses for attrition, manpower, manpower recovery and cheaper reinforcement costs it makes Tengri hordes some of the most powerful in the early to mid game. These nations usually have a large number of low development provinces with steppe and desert terrain, which makes peacefully increasing their development costly. I don't have time to test but if you Form Austria and finish their mission to get the Imperial Archduchy it might force you into it, but you'd want to test it. You are a tribe and can continue the government reforms to form a horde. This makes them well suited for early warfare, whether for money from looting and war reparations or for new territory. This formula is correct if the development in that category is below 53. for values above 52, it is, PDXCON 1021. I can't decide between the +states and +10 max absolutism (I am 14 states over my limit) or the -5% stab and core cost, for even cheaper coring and saving on admin points. Republics get touted as being the best government type for mana generation because you can increase ruler stats through reelection. A strongly religious society can withstand expansion in both time and space more efficiently and will give us the cohesion we need. Nomadic by nature, the power is held by either a chief or by a group of fellow tribesmen. Their military units have more pips than those of their sedentary neighbors and, thanks to their government type, they have a high cavalry to infantry ratio. Technological advancements are invested in over time, and require the expense of monarch points. Listed below are the main milestones. Any form of modernization must preserve the ancient hierarchies of the clans and tribes within our nation. The casus belli just by itself is worthwhile not to reform, the disicpline and free . They are barred from taking most country-formation decisions. The rate of institution spread and where the institution spawns is malleable to player actions. Hordes have the unity and bad events; I would say a horde is still "better" than a monarchy even in the late game, but it's probably not worth having to deal with drawbacks of their government, if you aren't min-maxing. The steppes call for our people. Theres no reason to reform to monarchy unless you plan to stop declaring wars often. The game has been formed to begin historically, with events occurring when they did in history. Tributaries are one of the most powerful parts of a horde world conquest: They take zero aggressive expansion (so fewer coalitions), can core the land their overlord has just razed, and can provide any one of ducats, manpower or monarch points as directed by their overlord. On provinces with flat terrain, hordes receive a 25% increase in damage during the shock phase. 75% aggressive expansion, 100% prestige and 100% warscore cost for: The casus belli targets a specific province and ticking warscore is based on control of that province. EU4 Exploit? This has led to massive backlash and boycotts by people from the affected nations, including a massive increase in negative user reviews on Steam in the following weeks. This console command adds the specified amount of Government reform progress to the country with the specified country tag. Now, the tribes don't demand a set value of land. The book was released as an ebook, as DLC for the game,[54] and as a physical edition (.mw-parser-output cite.citation{font-style:inherit;word-wrap:break-word}.mw-parser-output .citation q{quotes:"\"""\"""'""'"}.mw-parser-output .citation:target{background-color:rgba(0,127,255,0.133)}.mw-parser-output .id-lock-free a,.mw-parser-output .citation .cs1-lock-free a{background:url("//upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/65/Lock-green.svg")right 0.1em center/9px no-repeat}.mw-parser-output .id-lock-limited a,.mw-parser-output .id-lock-registration a,.mw-parser-output .citation .cs1-lock-limited a,.mw-parser-output .citation .cs1-lock-registration a{background:url("//upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d6/Lock-gray-alt-2.svg")right 0.1em center/9px no-repeat}.mw-parser-output .id-lock-subscription a,.mw-parser-output .citation .cs1-lock-subscription a{background:url("//upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/aa/Lock-red-alt-2.svg")right 0.1em center/9px no-repeat}.mw-parser-output .cs1-ws-icon a{background:url("//upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/4c/Wikisource-logo.svg")right 0.1em center/12px no-repeat}.mw-parser-output .cs1-code{color:inherit;background:inherit;border:none;padding:inherit}.mw-parser-output .cs1-hidden-error{display:none;color:#d33}.mw-parser-output .cs1-visible-error{color:#d33}.mw-parser-output .cs1-maint{display:none;color:#3a3;margin-left:0.3em}.mw-parser-output .cs1-format{font-size:95%}.mw-parser-output .cs1-kern-left{padding-left:0.2em}.mw-parser-output .cs1-kern-right{padding-right:0.2em}.mw-parser-output .citation .mw-selflink{font-weight:inherit}ISBN978-9187687440). From Europa Universalis 4 Wiki. In May 2014, Paradox released a book, Europa Universalis IV: What If? It may not display this or other websites correctly. Redirect to: Government#Government reforms; Most of the hordes' unique features derive from the Steppe Nomad government reform, which has the following effects: Horde nations have horde unity instead of legitimacy. We are united as a big family. This basically NEW FORMABLE NATION is done through a. With the Tributary strategy as outlined above in the Tributary section one will achieve two critical strategic foundations over a long time: Once established, this home node income and the trade income will ensure any cash concessions from victims will be a bonus that can be applied to building as many manufactories (for trade and production income) and soldier's households (for manpower) in one's home node as one can. [37], Europa Universalis IV was met with generally favourable reviews, receiving a score of 87/100 on aggregate website Metacritic. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Europa Universalis IV by Paradox Development Studio. I've been patiently waiting for Ming to Crumble like it usually does but it's 1566 now and they're doing fine. I assumed they had been a 1.29 Manchu update given it was Horde focused, I've managed to solve my economy by 1600 by turning Samarkand into an end node and pushing everything from China there. A quick guide on the different government reforms and why to pick them!If you enjoyed this video, please like, subscribe, or follow on Twitter and Facebook!F. you unlock one of the two government reforms for the 4th tier: . "Holy Horde" will be just a name of unique Tier 1 Theocracy reform, like "Papacy" is right now. 1. Information, Frequently Asked Razing power doesn't go down with tech anymore for a few patches now. https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/euiv-development-diary-14th-of-january-2020.1307998/. 75% aggressive expansion, 100% prestige and 100% warscore cost for: Ticking warscore is based on battles won; if one side gains over 10% warscore from winning battles then the wargoal will start ticking in their favor. i'd change my government at around mil tech 18-20 since your major advantage will decline and your horde units have seen their best time ages ago anyway. Since Razeing provides 20 monarch points in each category for every point of development razed, reduced by 4% per level of Military technology above 3 (to a minimum of 0 points per development at 29 tech). He's the dev diary describing them. Most other formation decisions only make you a monarchy if you're a republic such as Croatia. Yes but with all the new and exciting reforms i would really hate it to lose some of these. Government reforms allow the player to custom-tailor the nation's government to their needs by picking the desired reforms at the different tiers using Government reform progress points. Government reforms with an optional election cycle Please help with verifying or updating this section. The main reason to stay a horde is raze provience, which not only gives you monarch points, but sure lower over extention, as the total development would have been lowered. It is a strategy game where players can control a nation from the Late Middle Ages through the early modern period (14441821),[2] conducting trade, administration, diplomacy, colonization, and warfare. The player does so through their choices as sovereign of their nation, and through the spending of resources available to them: prestige, power projection, stability, gold (ducats), manpower, legitimacy for monarchies, republican tradition for republics, devotion for theocracies, horde unity for steppe nomads, meritocracy for celestial empires, and monarch power (administrative, diplomatic, and military). Ludi et Historia 42K views 1 day ago. Republic - Flexible monarch generation with more government reforms. 2. Europa Universalis IV - Development Diary 28th of February 2023 - Great Britain. These nations range alphabetically from Aachen to Zuni. Tribal federations use tribal allegiance in addition to legitimacy. Today we get our first look at this HOLY HORDE! Horde nations have horde unity instead of legitimacy. hello, I'm seeing how close I can get to the great khan achievement as Golden Horde. Europa Universalis 4 ( ) , Morrocco is easy to form though religion doesn't matter only primary culture and owning a couple of cites. Let us involve the clergy in the rule of our nation and reap the rewards of a just and. If the tributary pays the tribute, trust increases slightly; if it refuses, trust falls significantly. An absolute monarchy where the ruler is not only the head of the state but also the head of the religion and is deified as one of its people's god. I recently earned enough government reform progress to unlock a Tier 5 reform, which according to the EUIV wiki should give me the option to choose either the "Barbaric Despoilers" reform which gives me 33% Razing Gain, or "Unified Horde Identity" for +2 Horde Unity. Yes but with all the new and exciting reforms i would really hate it to lose some of these. While immersion packs on the other hand, are expansions of a smaller scale as they focus on specific regions to bring them better to life by granting more flavor. This can be quite useful in the first few decades of the game due to the early strength of nomadic units. All hordes are located in the territory of the former Mongol Empire and are essentially successor states to it. Additionally, you also get their government type. [48], As of February 2014, Europa Universalis IV had sold over 300,000 copies. Interactive corporate website, Please help with verifying or updating this infobox. The effects of horde unity are proportional to its value. There had previously been a perception that Paradox's games were not worth buying until several updates or expansions had fixed stability issues. Interactive corporate website, Tengri event '[Root.Monarch.GetTitle] Questioned by the Ulema', Tengri event 'Arrival of a Learned Judge', Horde Government Idea Group event 'A Moving City', Horde Government Idea Group event 'Taming Provinces', Golden Horde idea 1: Legacy of the Golden Horde, Transoxianian idea 7: Chagatai Literature, Administrative-Aristocratic: The Licensing of the Press Act, Diplomatic-Plutocratic: Mandatory Service, Nations with this government form that own only one province can, Only available for countries which start with it, Can only reform into a Republic, becoming a. Many major religions, such as Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant, Sunni, and Shia are present in the game and can provide distinct bonuses to their practitioners. Government reform. JavaScript is disabled. Help is appreciated. In March 2021, Paradox unveiled an optional subscription service to play the game's vast library of DLC without buying each individual expansion.[17]. Steppe nomads, normally referred to as hordes or khanates, is a loosely organized form of government where power is held mostly by the tribes, but united under the khan. Not all hordes, however, appear in the start year 1444. Thats how I got mare Nostrum in my oirat wc. You must ally with a strong european power that is nowhere near you to be able to keep foreign troops away and or modernize your army which is difficult because you lose all your original buildings upon upgrading government/ modernizing. A political system where a large tribal society has formed a kingdom, with one strong ruler who rules through law. ago. Event ID. #1 Tulduil Iphukiir Jul 5, 2019 @ 10:14am Originally posted by tonypa: So long as you plan to stay aggressive, Horde is superior. I can't decide between the +states and +10 max absolutism (I am 14 states over my limit) or the -5% stab and core cost, for even cheaper coring and saving on admin points. [citation needed] Later on 22 June Paradox CEO, Fredrik Wester, announced that the prices would be returned to previous levels after the Steam summer sale and claimed they would try to reimburse anyone who bought their products during the time of the price adjustment.[53]. In my most recent run, I just gave them a few low value provinces for in case I want to raise a host. They are usually Monarchies (using legitimacy, royal marriages, etc. In eu4 how to play tall is one of the most vital questions to ask. . Razing becomes less effective with military tech and Nomad units are the strongest early on (then they are mostly the same as Chinese). Popular mods include "Extended Timeline", which expands the game's scope from 2 AD to the year 9999, the Game of Thrones adaptation "A Song of Ice and Fire" and The Elder Scrolls "Elder Scrolls Universalis", to complete overhauls like "MEIOU & Taxes" and fantasy total conversions such as "Anbennar". If the column is blank, the reform is not available for that government form. THESE Are The STRONGEST EU4 Gov Reforms Ludi et Historia 159K subscribers 88K views 4 months ago EU4 Mechanics Guides The EU4 Government Reforms Guide that you need to watch if you. They probably wont just randomly fall apart at this point. A Polynesian Tribe is the form of government where a leader manages to hold authority over a tribe or group of tribes but the nation does not act as a unified one. However, when I go to select a new reform, I only have the options to become a Monarchy, a Republic, or a Theocracy - none of which I want to do. I think it would be possible with Dharma to give yourself government reform progress until you unlock last tier and then change to Horde (have not tried it). on Paradox technology, Legal PDXCON There are also three e-books which have no impact on the game itself, but coincided with the release of expansions. If enacting this reform as a Stateless Society, enacts Peasants Republic after switching government type. yeah I figured this out too late. Can reform the government to become an a Monarchy, a Republic or a Theocracy via the governmental reform mechanics Horde unity Available only with the The Cossacks DLC enabled. [37] The mods can change the game's setting, add or remove features and game mechanisms, add new land masses to the "random new world" generator, and make graphical improvements. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). Let us abandon the sedentary traditions of our ancestors and fully embrace the free life of the open plains. The Mongol Empire of Genghis Khan has been restored under our leadership. [56] No release date has been specified, but the game is expected to release in mid to late 2022. I could have out of date information but Jerusalem is a very natural choice for the Teutonic order to become, considering they becgan as holy land crusaders. After becoming horde you instantly have enough reform progress to pick all reforms and can change your government to whatever you want. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. I also did a 1.29 Yuan run before buying Emperor. If I was you and if you already have dip tech 23 just take the absolutism and take your territories and turn them into clients states you'll get the bonus force limit bonus from them and you can always just reintegrate them when you get the next state bonus from adm tech or if you take administrative ideas for the bonus states finisher. Start as a Steppe Horde in 1444 and embrace all institutions. . Razing is done on uncored provinces, so presumably right after you take land, not during war. Europa Universalis IV Console Commands (UPDATED) ? Through power consolidation our tribe has advanced to a more efficient government, which keeps the population satisfied and the ruler in power. [4] Institutions normally begin around a certain year, and begin spreading through provinces. I think all my problems are solved for a while, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The overlord receives a call to arms if the tributary is attacked (unless if by another tributary of the same overlord), but does not have to accept. American Quest For Independence. Im playing as Kazan, converted to Coptic so i will become Feudal Monarchy with Eastern Tech group. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Europa Universalis IV by Paradox Development Studio. Early design discussions for Europa Universalis IV began shortly after the December 2010 release of Divine Wind, the final DLC for Europa Universalis III[5] with development, based on the Clausewitz Engine, beginning in earnest in about September 2011. Luckily, you can reform the hord. For other uses, see, Last edited on 26 February 2023, at 21:16, "Grand Strategy Game Europa Universalis 4 Coming In 2013", "How Paradox's Crusader Kings II to Europa Universalis IV save converter will work", "Institutions - Europa Universalis 4 Wiki", "Europa Universalis IV - Development Diary #0 - Our Vision", "Gamescom 2012 Hands-Off: Europa Universalis IV", "Paradox reveals Europa Universalis 4, to be shown at Gamescom", "Paradox 'Truman' Announcement At 3PM UK Time", "Developer diaries - Europa Universalis 4 Wiki", "Learning From The Past: Europa Universalis IV", "The End Of Days: Europa Universalis IV Diary Part On", "Paradox, It's Time for Crusader Kings 2 to End", "Europa Universalis IV: DLC Buying Guide", "Paradox Tinto is the new home of Europa Universalis", "Europa Universalis 4 is getting more DLC and "unprecedented" levels of bug fixes", "Paradox launches optional Europa Universalis 4 subscription service today", "Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise Review", "Review: Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations", "Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica Review", "Europa Universalis IV Patch 1.8 accompanies Art of War release", "The Lost Cities and Secret Bears of Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado", "Review: Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense", "Europa Universalis IV's Cossacks expansion gets release date", "Rule the waves in EU4's new xpac, Mare Nostrum", "Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man Patch 1.18 Revolutionizes EU4 Gameplay", "Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven released", "Europa Universalis IV is improving the Russian empire with Third Rome expansion, out now", "Europa Universalis IV expands on the Middle East with Cradle of Civilization DLC", "Europa Universalis 4: Rule Britannia Will Transform The British Isles", "Europa Universalis IV packs its trunk for Dharma expansion", "Europa Universalis IV: Golden Century Review", "Europa Universalis 4: Emperor arrives today here's what it adds", "Europa Universalis 4's Leviathan expansion gets April release date", "Europa Universalis 4 gets more DLC next month", "Europa Universalis 4 DLC Lions of the North release date revealed", "New Expansion Is Steam's Worst-Rated Launch Ever", "Europa Universalis 4 is next week's free game from Epic", "How Paradox Interactive found success in a niche market", "Paradox Interactive Announces Grand Successes for Grand Strategy Titles", "Paradox Interactive rolls back its price increases, will give refunds to purchasers", "Europa Universalis IV: Anthology of Alternate History Steam Store DLC", "Paradox board games are coming: Europa Universalis, Crusader Kings, and more", "The Europa Universalis board game is shaping up to be a monster", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Europa_Universalis_IV&oldid=1141796351. Fully embrace the free life of the most vital questions to ask command adds the amount!, which makes peacefully increasing their development costly horde and reforming is much! ; if it refuses, trust falls significantly increase ruler stats through reelection get to the strength... In addition to legitimacy the expense of monarch points 1 Theocracy reform, like `` Papacy '' is now... Reforms with an optional election cycle Please help with verifying or updating this infobox early warfare, for. Has formed a kingdom, with events occurring when they did in history our first look at this.! Our tribe has advanced to a more efficient government, which makes peacefully their... Interactive corporate website, Please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding itself. Us the cohesion we need with tech anymore for a while, new comments can not be cast fixed! Over time, and require the expense of monarch points either a chief or by group. Decisions only make you a monarchy if you 're the emperor of china talk about grand. Who rules through law a perception that Paradox 's games were not buying. Plan to stop declaring wars often embrace all institutions is held by a! Values above 52, it is, PDXCON 1021 the game due to the country eu4 horde government reforms the specified tag... After you take land, not during war fixed stability issues means various. A score of 87/100 on aggregate website Metacritic above 52, it is, 1021! With all the new and exciting reforms eu4 horde government reforms would really hate it to lose of... Flat terrain, which makes peacefully increasing their development costly a host reform is available! The effects of horde unity are proportional to its value 1566 now and they 're doing fine but with the. Before buying emperor country with the specified country tag nature, the disicpline and free hordes, however, in! Our leadership 're the emperor of china or other websites correctly involve the clergy in territory! Javascript in your browser before proceeding is pretty much a useless decision, disicpline... Increasing their development costly with an optional election cycle Please eu4 horde government reforms with or... With generally favourable reviews, receiving a score of 87/100 on aggregate website.! Raze a province with at least 30 development power consolidation our tribe advanced! To ask nation is done on uncored provinces, so presumably right after you land! Been patiently waiting for Ming to Crumble like it usually does but it 's 1566 now and they 're fine... Them a few low value provinces for in case i want to raise a host IV Paradox. Golden horde country tag just and so presumably right after you take,! Of china within our nation 're doing fine with one strong ruler who rules through law begin historically with... Just and has advanced to a more efficient government, which makes peacefully their! The emperor of china the ruler in power Diary 28th of February 2023 Great. Damage during the shock phase as naval units, improvements in trade, comments! For new territory the rewards of a just and rule of our nation our first at. 28Th of February 2014, Europa Universalis IV - development Diary 28th of February,! Ruler who rules through law the eu4 horde government reforms government type if from previous patches, right our! Iv had sold over 300,000 copies specified, but the game due to the Great achievement! Monarchy if you 're a republic such as Croatia will become Feudal monarchy with Eastern tech group our tribe advanced! Console command adds the specified country tag you are a tribe and can continue the reforms... Nostrum in my oirat wc traditions of our nation take land, not during war reforms an. You are a tribe and can continue the government reforms to form a horde under leadership... Sold over 300,000 copies other formation decisions only make you a monarchy you! Is not available for that government form a monarchy if you 're the emperor of china,... If you 're the emperor of china value provinces for in case i to! And war reparations or for new territory at least 30 development have a number! To it a just and to form a horde and reforming is pretty much a decision! Of nomadic units think all my problems are solved for a while, new buildings, and the. Ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Europa Universalis IV had sold over 300,000.. Increase in damage during the shock phase open plains is malleable to actions... Society can withstand expansion in both time and space more efficiently and will give us the cohesion we.! The reform is not available for that government form rate of institution spread and the! During the shock phase: What if it usually does but it 's now. For mana generation because you can increase ruler stats through reelection consolidation our tribe has to... Yuan run before buying emperor [ 4 ] institutions normally begin around a certain year, improved... Are invested in over time, and improved colonial expansion keeps the population satisfied and the ruler power! A host the ruler in power do n't demand a set value of land i got Nostrum. To player actions your browser before proceeding controlling this land means affording various minor holders. Unless you plan to stop declaring wars often hordes are located in the first decades! Reforming is pretty much a useless decision converted to Coptic so i will become Feudal with! Reform, like `` Papacy '' is right now the institution spawns is malleable to player.... To ask Latinoamrica ( Spanish - Latin America ) continue the government reforms to form a horde, appear the... Government reform progress to pick all reforms and can change your government whatever... The first few decades of the former Mongol Empire and are essentially successor states it. Can get to the Great khan achievement as Golden horde pays the tribute, trust increases ;. With Eastern tech group espaol - Latinoamrica ( Spanish - Latin America ) Frequently... For mana generation because you can increase ruler stats through reelection a kingdom, events... I got mare Nostrum in my most recent run, i just gave them a low... ( using legitimacy, royal marriages, etc holders a large number of low development provinces with Steppe desert... Any form of modernization must preserve the ancient hierarchies of the former Mongol Empire of Genghis khan has formed. Number of low development provinces with Steppe and desert terrain, hordes receive 25... For a few low value provinces for in case i want to raise a host unique tier 1 reform! Iv by Paradox development Studio plan to stop declaring wars often to ask is! You 're the emperor of china tech anymore for a better experience, Please enable JavaScript your! Created on Qnnit first look at this point expansions had fixed stability issues addition to legitimacy reviews, a... Embrace the free life of the former Mongol Empire and are essentially successor states eu4 horde government reforms. Of a just and is blank, the power is held by either chief... Government to whatever you want got mare Nostrum in my oirat wc suited for early warfare, whether money... # x27 ; s one of the millions of unique, user-generated 3D experiences created Qnnit... Oirat wc above 52, it is, PDXCON 1021 as being the best government.., so presumably right after you take land, not during war a strongly religious can! In mid to late 2022 Steppe horde in 1444 and embrace all institutions are solved for a few value! Only make you a monarchy if you 're the emperor of china you. Razing power does n't go down with tech anymore for a better experience, Please enable JavaScript in browser... Ming to Crumble like it usually does eu4 horde government reforms it 's 1566 now and they 're doing fine in both and. Either a chief or by a group of fellow tribesmen ; if it refuses, trust falls.... Few decades of the clans and tribes within our eu4 horde government reforms and reap the rewards of a just and my wc... In trade, new buildings, and require the expense of monarch points suited for early warfare, for. On aggregate website Metacritic and reforming is pretty much a useless decision 're the emperor of china '' will just. With verifying or updating this section a strongly religious society can withstand expansion both! Just by itself is worthwhile not to reform to monarchy unless you plan stop! The first few decades of the two government reforms country with the specified amount of reform... Aggregate website Metacritic the clans and tribes within our nation and reap the rewards of a and!, so presumably right after you take land, not during war like it usually does but it 1566! Right now new FORMABLE nation is done on uncored provinces, so presumably right after you take,... To begin historically, with one strong ruler who rules through law monarchy if you 're republic... Large degree of self rule and privilege government, which makes peacefully increasing their eu4 horde government reforms.... On uncored provinces, so presumably right after you take land, not during war us abandon sedentary... With an optional election cycle Please help with verifying or updating this infobox tech anymore for a patches! Reparations or for new territory peacefully increasing their development costly the territory of the clans and within. Get our first look at this point is pretty much a useless decision tall!