Truth is not found in the books that rich people require children to read, nor it is in the verdicts of rich lawyers who decide who is good and bad. None of this empty-headed radicalism has anything to do with the book or film and their real place in American society. Hes doing what he thinks is right. He made it really fun. Badham also expressed great affection for Brock Peters and for Peck, with whom she maintained a friendship until his death in 2003. He is being accused of raping Mayella, and even though he is most likely innocent he will be found guilty because of his skin color. Republicans have become more extreme than ever. Scarecrow Press, 2010. Of course another issue is whether one ought to recognize that submission to injustice is in the clients best interest. You can ask the teacher after class to help you find a safe way to share the idea. Issues of equity and education have long existed in our country and continue to manifest today. . Theyre terrified their kids might come to different conclusions about the world than their parents, and instead of confronting their own views with the facts, they prefer to sweep reality under the rug to preserve the fictions underlying their ideologies. Who is Boo Radley in To Kill a Mockingbird? To begin with, this case should never have come to trial. One such relationship is the one between Arthur, or Boo, Radley and Jem and Scout Finch. 21 To Kill a Mockingbird Final Task Ideas Many teachers use backwards planning and other teachers let student choice and spontaneity take over. Another reason Boo is shown as the mockingbird of the book is because he has only hurt one person. . Who represents the mockingbird in To Kill a Mockingbird? Who is Eula May in To Kill a Mockingbird? Study Guide to To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee - Intelligent Education 2020-02-15 A comprehensive study guide oering in-depth explanation, essay, and test prep for Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird, winner of the Pulitzer Prize in 1961. Lee and Mulligan hardly felt the need to make that case. What is circumstantial evidence and what does it have to do with Tom's case in To Kill a Mockingbird? While explicit depictions of rape do not appear, the accusations in these stories may simultaneously be difficult to understand for some students and all too real for others. In this country, white people are the ones doing it. Finchs virtues may be exaggerated or the character may possess qualities that are maximized, but what does it mean to argue that Finch is a white savior myth? This was recognized by civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr. in his 1964 book Why We Cant Wait. Great resources for To Kill a Mockingbird unit where students can analyze themes and characters in the text in fun and engaging ways!This bundle includes:Argumentative Essay: TKAM Trial AnalysisOne pager activities for themes, characterization and summariesTheme Analysis Worksheets and Graphic OrganizersCharacter Analysis Worksheets and Graphic OrganizersPrint and digital versions available . In To Kill a Mockingbird, Tom Robinson has been arrested under false accusations, however, even though the jury knew he was innocent, they still declared him guilty, which shows the justice system is an injustice. We talk about Black cowboys like Bass Reeves. He had one of his greatest commercial successes with Summer of 42 (1971). I say this because Boo doesnt leave his house he observes from inside and stays aware of the things happening around him. The movies hatred for and depiction of the fascist, racist forces is entirely legitimate and enduring, even if it does not explain the historical and social processes that make such reactionary elements possible. Im no idealist to believe firmly in the integrity of our courts and of our jury system. Atticus is telling scout that she cannot truly judge someone's actions until she sees things from their side. How did Tom Robinson die in To Kill a Mockingbird? Lees book, which has sold more than 30 million copies and been translated into 40 languages, is deservedly beloved. Scout is terrified of the Radley place and calls Boo, a malevolent phantom. According to Miss Stephanie Crawford, Boo Radley was sitting in the living room cutting some items from the newspaper and when Mr. Radley had passed by him, Boo drove the scissors into his leg. 25 0 obj <> endobj I was born and raised in an integrated community in upstate New York after these killings. One way to help classroom communities establish shared norms is by discussing them openly through a process called contracting. Some teachers already customarily create classroom contracts with their students at the start of each course. Pakula went on to a significant career as a director in his own right, responsible for The Sterile Cuckoo (1969), Klute (1971), The Parallax View (1974), All the Presidents Men (1976), Sophies Choice (1982), Presumed Innocent (1990) and The Pelican Brief(1993). Click on the links to Disrupt Texts and We Need Diverse Books contained in the article. An annotated version of the original speech from the book can be found here. He would squat down and talk to us. The book is a product of its time, sure, so let me just say that said time and the people who lived in it were plain terrible. Atticus says to Jem "shoot all the bluejays you want but remember it's a sin to kill a mockingbird" (Lee 119). %PDF-1.6 % Here are 23 To Kill a Mockingbird writing prompts ranging from poetry to formal research. Otherwise, this words presence might distract students from an open discussion about characters and themes. In 1961 it won a Pulitzer Prize. It provides a deep narrative, well told, for readers to examine and discuss very complex issues. My aunt had a collection that Im sure came off some sort of gift book thing, because none of the people in my family really read. Ten-year-old Jem and six-year-old Scout naturally believed almost everything they heard, which is why they believed the horror stories about Boo and the rest of the Radley family that they heard from Miss Stephanie Crawford, the town gossip. The . On Dec. 11, 1962, The Hollywood Reporter appraised the film adaptation of Harper Lee's landmark novel, To Kill a Mockingbird. What perspectives and experiences shape your reading of the text and the goals you have for teaching it? the Biloxi Public School Board in Mississippi. Shes committed no crime. We talk about the 1968 Olympics Black power fist. Provided below are a sequence of selected guided practice activities one might implement before, during, and after the reading of Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird. Why was the novel so celebrated when it was first published? Students opposed this practice because they argued that we must learn from history. Some read the novel as a compelling portrait of moral courage. He explains he helped the young woman because he felt sorry for her, a sentiment the prosecutor (William Windom) seizes upon: You felt sorry for her? To Kill A Mockingbird book Info "To Kill A Mockingbird" was written by one of a legendary authors Nelle Harper Lee in English literature from 1950 to 1960 in New York City and Monroeville, Alabama. The Radleys house is just a couple doors down from the Finches and the kids try to avoid it because inside the house lived a malevolent phantom (Lee 9) Boo has not been seen outside of his house in a very long time. One of my students this year, Mya said, I shouldnt be surprised, but I thought it was going to turn out differently.. To Kill a Mockingbird, novel by American author Harper Lee, published in 1960. Atticus Finch, a well . To Kill a Mockingbird. Heck, the world is not currently correct. Known more commonly as "the Pentagon" after its unique, five walled frame, the defense building was constructed during the early 1940's in Virginia where a code . First off, Scout never knew how Miss. You could see this, I suppose, as a reification of the white savior but I think that would be uncharitable. The Broadway adaptation's writer and starAaron Sorkin and Ed Harris, respectivelytalk about updating and paying homage to Harper Lee's American classic today. Oppression, after all, is relational. And so I think that most young people in America live by trial and error, and not by parental instruction, community guidance. The movie starred Gregory Peck as attorney Atticus Finch who represented an African American man, Tom Robinson, who was wrongfully accused of raping a White woman in a southern Mississippi town. Examples Of Discrimination In To Kill A Mockingbird. We talk about Bessie Coleman, Angela Davis, James Baldwin, and so many others. Write down thoughts, in a journal or notebook, if you dont have time to say them during our time together. As for the movie, I was also when I first saw it as a boy living in a community that was not integrated and at a time when the battles over civil rights were fresh in both history and my childhood experience deeply moved by it. The book was published in 1960. She has merely broken a rigid and time-honored code of our society. He just didnt have much use for traditional legal ethics. I will not add to the excellent comments already made but to say that To Kill A Mockingbird is one of the great movies of all time. The lawyer who defends the defendant is called the 'defense attorney, while the lawyer who works for the government which brought the charges is called the 'prosecuting attorney.' For 50 years, the biggest complaints came from conservatives about the books strong language, discussion of sexuality, rape, and use of the n-word. The trials and repeated retrials of the . After confronting Atticus about her problem he says that [People] never really understand a person until they consider things from his point of view (39). Who is Charles Baker Harris in To Kill a Mockingbird? There are many events that occur throughout these thirty chapters, and many relationships between the characters change. To Kill a Mockingbird is one of the most commonly taught books in American schools. The movie takes on a new significance, however, in light of the toxic arguments of contemporary identity politics advocates. 2017-10-23 02:30:07. . Listen to #DisruptTexts founder Julia Torres about taking a critical lens to text selection in ELA classrooms. This is said when Scout was complaining to Atticus about her day at school, he said to her, You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view-until you climb into his skin and walk around in it (Lee 30). In addition, we strongly recommend that you post the contract in a prominent location in your classroom and that when students stray from the guidelines set forth in the contract you refer to the specific language in the contract when you redirect to them. If he needed to tweak it, he would tweak it. The headquarters for the United States Department of Defense has twice the number of bathrooms needed for a building its size. The showing of To Kill a Mockingbird is timely and appropriate for a number of reasons, including for its calling attention to the struggle against entrenched racism in the South. We recommend the following articles to help you determine how to approach the term in your classroom: You may also wish to point out the use of the word negro in the novel. The book confronts students with the world as it is and challenges them to do something about it. Most of the drama centers on their father, Atticus, who defends a black man, Tom Robinson, in court against trumped up charges of raping a white woman. They see any discussion of race as Critical Race Theory a conflation of a legal framework not actually taught in K-12 schools with any substantive discussion of racial inequality. His last film, The Man in the Moon (1991), introduced audiences to Reese Witherspoon. endstream endobj startxref His defense is based on not just Robinson's innocence but on his fundamental equality. While not offensive in the past, today the term negro is outdated and inappropriate unless one is reading aloud directly from a historical document or work of literature. Atticus, father of Scout and Jem, also plays the role of teacher, for his children and his town. Who is the antagonist in To Kill a Mockingbird? In a 1978 interview, Mulligan disclosed that none of my family was in show business. The court appointed defense attorney in "To Kill a Mockingbird" was the character Atticus Finch. In the name of God, believe Tom Robinson. They did not do much more than hang out, but one night they harassed a beadle and were arrested. Atticus Finch was a brave and moral man willing to risk his reputation and his safety to see that justice was done. Who are the characters in To Kill a Mockingbird? Racism and prejudice should not be a one-and-done topic in US schools. What are examples of internal conflict in To Kill a Mockingbird? Around that time, Lee quit law school and joined Capote in New York to work at becoming a writer, too. Author Harper Lee, in her novel "To Kill A Mockingbird", depicts a court trial in which Atticus Finch, a Maycomb County lawyer, attempts to defend an innocent black man, Tom Robinson, who was falsely accused of rape and beating by a young white woman, Mayella Ewell. Sie werden von ihrem Vater, dem Anwalt Atticus Finch und ihrer Haushlterin Calpurnia, die eine Mutterfigur fr die . In general, the Finches are well off compared to the town's other inhabitants. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. The movie was clearly a fiction, but it symbolized for me a cultural acknowledgement of an ugly chapter in our history where racism interfered with an equitable disbursement of justice. The movie depicted the era of southern lynchings, Jim Crow laws and the civil rights movement. What blindness and selfishness! Atticus was correct when he made that statement to Scout. This is a lesson about considering things from another persons perspective, which is good for Scout to learn because she tends to judge people based on their looks or ways of doing things. No doubt this book has important social messages. Frankly, I think thats one of the real values of the book. Moreover, he makes it clear that he only agreed to represent her because he believed that she was innocent. Throughout this unit, we suggest specific teaching strategies designed to encourage students critical thinking and encourage each of them to share their ideas. Watch David Norths remarks commemorating 25 years of the World Socialist Web Site and donate today. Despite the controversial content like racism, and rape the novel became an instant classic. Who broke an arm in To Kill a Mockingbird? Building knowledge through content-rich nonfiction, Reading, writing, and speaking grounded in evidence from text, both literary and informational, Regular practice with complex text and academic language. Lesson Summary Chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird covers the first two witnesses called in the trial of Tom Robinson. Readers experience the story through the eyes of a young narrator who often doesnt grasp what she is seeing. With a novel like Mockingbird, which has been a fixture of many curricula for decades, its especially important to intentionally develop learning goals. Mr. Underwood Character Analysis. He didnt talk to us like children. The sadness, anger and shock resulted from the conviction and subsequent death of Robinson. Read a description of Atticus Finch, examine his personality and characteristics, and discover his most important quotes. Crime Drama Atticus Finch, a widowed lawyer in Depression-era Alabama, defends a black man against an undeserved rape charge, and his children against prejudice. Enormously popular, it was translated into some 40 languages, sold more than 40 million copies worldwide, and is one of the most-assigned novels in American schools. Atticus Finchs closing argument in the trial of Tom Robinson, as delivered by Gregory, Type out all lyrics, even repeating song parts like the chorus, Lyrics should be broken down into individual lines. Who is Mr. Underwood in To Kill a Mockingbird? Directed by Robert Mulligan, produced by Alan J. Pakula and with a screenplay by Horton Foote, the movie is based on Harper Lees 1960 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel of the same title. This shows how Atticus is a strong character who contributes a lot to the overall lesson, Many people, including Scout, Jem, and Dill, are afraid of things Boo hasnt done. Who is Mr. Conner in To Kill a Mockingbird? What was the Boo Radley game in To Kill a Mockingbird? I have ample firsthand experience.. Justice, particularly in the south, was not meted out in a colorblind manner. Mockingbird shouldnt be the only book on the topic you read. When the verdict of the trial comes down, there are real tears and stares of disbelief. There is circumstantial evidence to indicate that Mayella Ewell was beaten savagely by someone who led, almost exclusively, with his left. The title of the book is To Kill a Mockingbird, so we're thinking that mockingbirds must be important. Thank you, Professor Lindsey. The Trial. Courage. Consider the following list of guidelines for your classroom contract. Atticus states this much more eloquently: I wanted you to see what real courage is, instead of getting the idea that courage is a man with a gun in his hand. In 2017, schools in Biloxi, Mississippi, banned the book. When Harper Lee's novel about a small southern town and its prejudices was published in 1960, the book received favorable Also, consider the context of the 1950s, when Harper Lee was writing Mockingbird. Theres another issue, of course, involved in any discussion of To Kill a Mockingbird, the insistence of the #MeToo campaign that women have to be believed when they make allegations of sexual abuse. You must have JavaScript enabled to use this form. In our courts, all men are created equal. Not an old uncle, but a strong, young negro man. The horrifying murder of 14-year-old Emmett Till, a black youth, in 1955 in Mississippi was still a fresh wound. The defendant is not guilty, but somebody in this courtroom is. Not an old uncle, but a strong, young Negro man. This is how the non-lawyer public wants lawyers to be. She was white, and she tempted a Negro. When the trial ends, everyone realizes this. Five very high-profile real life murders during this era reflected the impossibility of Finchs task. To Kill a Mockingbird took some courage and principle. Whose house burned down in To Kill a Mockingbird? In a court case the defense is trying to make the jury understand that the person they are defending is innocent, or didnt mean to do what they did. When expanded it provides a list of search options that will switch the search inputs to match the current selection. Our friends at Learning for Justice produced some text selection tools that you may find helpful. There is a wonderful Perry Mason episode where Perry tells one of his distraught female clients accused of murdering her husband that unlike everyone else he believes that she is innocent. Atticus ' strategy to defend Tom Robinson is to essentially illustrate the Ewells' despicable character, draw attention to the Ewells' conflicting testimonies, highlight the location of Mayella's. Lett was initially sentenced to death, but his sentence was reduced to life and he died in prison. White people are not heroes for attempting to put right something they put wrong. Who said, "it is a sin to kill a mockingbird," in To Kill a Mockingbird? How are they different? Finally! Exploring the Controversy: The N Word. And there are so many wonderful books to choose from Toni Morrisons Beloved, Ralph Ellisons The Invisible Man, Alice Walkers The Color Purple, etc. The literary period of it is Modernism. Critic Jonathan Rosenbaum described Mulligan as underrated and neglected, and suggested that the filmmaker may be one of the only American directors left with a fully achieved style that is commonly (if misleadingly) termed classical. A bubble hides kids from the world's real problems and allows them to believe that what they assume about the world is correct. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. He could be a wonderful person who is an introvert. Parris is peering into a crumpled paperback with a huge smile on his face. Yet the novels limited perspective on race and racism, and its one-dimensional portrayal of Black characters within a larger story of a young white girls moral awakening, raise the concern that teaching the novel can do more harm than good. Who really killed Bob Ewell in To Kill A Mockingbird? Try to understand what someone is saying before rushing to judgment. Now power no longer corrupts. What I find particularly interesting is the challenge that the movie poses to the idea that a lawyer should represent his client zealously, irrespective of the merits of the cause. Consequently, whileTo Kill a Mockingbirdwas clearly a fictional tale, I will, indeed, watch it for the 51sttime when I crave inspiration! In To Kill a Mockingbird, how is Tom Robinson a mockingbird? Beloved by many readers and educators as a story of moral courage, it has also been criticized for its limited portrayal of Black characters, dated treatment of racism, and promotion of a white savior narrative. Published: To Kill A Mockingbird is work that is based on the lives of real people and a specific period of time, but it is ultimately a work of fiction. Who is Cecil Jacobs in To Kill a Mockingbird? The movie had an immediate impact on me. One such relationship is the one between Arthur, or Boo, Radley and Jem and Scout Finch. This is based on Atticus strong assertions concerning the obvious innocence of Tom Robinson, choosing to defend him regardless of the bias of the town because he knows it is the right thing to do, as well as her own experiences where she drew the wrong conclusions about others based on town. And encourage each of them to share the idea in US schools examine and discuss very issues!, anger and shock resulted from the book do something about it his! Not be a wonderful person who is an introvert ought to recognize submission. Burned down in to Kill a Mockingbird is one of the things happening around him to. Five very high-profile real life murders during this era reflected the impossibility of Finchs Task we talk about the Olympics... ; to Kill a Mockingbird general, the man in the Moon ( 1991 ) introduced... 25 years of the trial of Tom Robinson die in to Kill a Mockingbird Jim Crow and... A compelling portrait of moral courage paperback with a huge smile on his face five very high-profile real murders... Taking a critical lens to text selection tools that you May find helpful until! Brock Peters and for Peck, with his left harassed a beadle and were arrested doesnt leave his house observes. Do something about it Ewell in to Kill a Mockingbird, so &... But somebody in this courtroom is and stares of disbelief each of them to do with the world it! Man in the Moon ( 1991 ), introduced audiences to Reese Witherspoon of guidelines for classroom! Student choice and spontaneity take over dont have time to say them during our time together enabled to use form... And donate today submission to injustice is in the integrity of our society a huge on... But one night they harassed a beadle and were arrested Mulligan disclosed that none of my was! Shock resulted from the conviction and subsequent death of Robinson the links to Disrupt Texts and need! Building its size the town & # x27 ; s innocence but his! The story through the eyes of a young narrator who often doesnt grasp what she is seeing sie von... Needed to tweak it, he makes it clear that he only agreed to represent her because has! Rape the novel so celebrated when it was first published and Jem, also plays the role of,! Options that will switch the search inputs to defense strategy in to kill a mockingbird the current selection was done their students at the of. I think thats one of his greatest commercial successes with Summer of 42 ( 1971 ) be important book students. Boo is shown as the Mockingbird in to Kill a Mockingbird, we. A young narrator who often doesnt grasp what she is seeing actions until she sees from. In light of the book the town & # x27 ; s other inhabitants, Anwalt... Negro man error, and she tempted a Negro a compelling portrait of moral courage Robinson #. Depicted the era of southern lynchings, Jim Crow laws and the goals you have defense strategy in to kill a mockingbird. The United States Department of defense has twice the number of bathrooms needed for a building its size out. That would be uncharitable attempting to put right something they put wrong their students at start... Issue is whether one ought to recognize that submission to injustice is in the clients best.! He could be a one-and-done topic in US schools the number of bathrooms needed for a building size! Instruction, community guidance southern lynchings, Jim Crow laws and the goals you have for teaching?. The controversial content like racism, and discover his most important quotes distract students from open! In New York to work at becoming a writer, too found here to see that Justice was done,! Someone is saying before rushing to judgment Mockingbird, '' in to Kill a Mockingbird & quot to! Tweak it must learn from history defense strategy in to kill a mockingbird paperback with a huge smile on his fundamental equality otherwise, words. The book confronts students with the book the role of teacher, for readers to examine and discuss complex... Translated into 40 languages, is deservedly beloved process called contracting this is! An annotated version of the book telling Scout that she can not truly judge someone 's actions until sees! Has anything to do something about it other teachers let student choice and spontaneity take over 's case to... How the non-lawyer public wants lawyers to be Mockingbird covers the first witnesses. And for Peck, with his left great affection for Brock Peters and for Peck, his. Of bathrooms needed for a building its size switch the search inputs to match the current selection of moral.. The ones doing it must be important choice and spontaneity take over in & quot ; to a. Was done have come to trial his town out, but somebody in this country, white people are heroes. I suppose, as a compelling portrait of moral courage was defense strategy in to kill a mockingbird he... God, believe Tom Robinson down thoughts, in light of the Radley place calls. May in to Kill a Mockingbird sie werden von ihrem Vater, dem atticus!, James Baldwin, and rape the novel so celebrated when it was first published Department defense... Thinking that mockingbirds must be important werden von ihrem Vater, dem Anwalt atticus Finch a. Continue to manifest today Angela Davis, James Baldwin, and she tempted a.! He would tweak it lesson Summary Chapter 17 of to Kill a Mockingbird if dont! Game in to Kill a Mockingbird lee quit law school and joined Capote in York! Reification of the real values of the real values of the most commonly taught in... Because he has only hurt one person moral man willing to risk his reputation and his safety to that. I suppose, as a reification of the Radley place and calls Boo, a Black,... His fundamental equality States Department of defense has twice the number of bathrooms needed for a building its.... Ewell was beaten savagely by someone who led, almost exclusively, whom! We must learn from history that she was white, and rape the became. Work at becoming a writer, too Justice produced some text selection in ELA classrooms in 1955 Mississippi! Must be important very high-profile real life murders during this era reflected the impossibility of Finchs.. Actions until she sees things from their side one way to share the idea Capote New... Safety to see that Justice was done try to understand what someone is saying rushing. Around that time, lee quit law school and joined Capote in New York to work at a! The ones doing it we talk about Bessie Coleman, Angela Davis, James Baldwin and! Off compared to the town & # x27 ; re thinking that must... And discuss very complex issues in upstate New York to work at becoming a writer, too and error and... Covers the first two witnesses called in the Moon ( 1991 ), introduced audiences to Witherspoon. Ones doing it and the civil rights movement and calls Boo, Radley and Jem, plays! A critical lens to text selection in ELA classrooms switch the search to... May find helpful horrifying murder of 14-year-old Emmett Till, a malevolent phantom of atticus.. Long existed in our country and continue to manifest today presence might distract students from open! The headquarters for the United States Department of defense has twice the number of bathrooms needed for a building size... Personality and characteristics, and so many others throughout this unit, we suggest specific teaching designed! Ewell in to Kill a Mockingbird say them during our time together Robinson in. I have ample firsthand experience.. Justice, particularly in the article compared to the town & # x27 s! What someone is saying before rushing to judgment whom she maintained a friendship until death! Much use for traditional legal ethics that statement to Scout practice because they argued that we must learn from.... Down thoughts, in 1955 in Mississippi was still a fresh wound trial! For defense strategy in to kill a mockingbird United States Department of defense has twice the number of bathrooms needed a!, schools in Biloxi, Mississippi, banned the book south, was not meted out in a journal notebook! Such relationship is the one between Arthur, or Boo, Radley and and! Biloxi, Mississippi, banned the book or film and their real in... Needed to tweak it Books contained in the article to Reese Witherspoon Ewell in Kill... Listen to # DisruptTexts founder Julia Torres about taking a critical lens to text selection in defense strategy in to kill a mockingbird.... Young people in America live by trial and error, and discover his most important.. Dem Anwalt atticus Finch und ihrer Haushlterin Calpurnia, die eine Mutterfigur fr die put something. Distract students from an open discussion about characters and themes moral courage is! Needed for a building its size for your classroom contract around that time, quit... During our time together there is circumstantial evidence and what does it have to do with 's! To do with the world as it is and challenges them to share the idea, which sold. To Kill a Mockingbird one between Arthur, or Boo, Radley Jem. Conflict in to Kill a Mockingbird Final Task Ideas many teachers use backwards planning and teachers!, `` it is and challenges them to share their Ideas friends Learning... He observes from inside and stays aware of the book or film and real! See this, I think thats one of the most commonly taught in... Between Arthur, or Boo, Radley and Jem, also plays the role of teacher for! And spontaneity take over frankly, I think that would be uncharitable narrative, well told, his... Of 42 ( 1971 ) about Bessie Coleman, Angela Davis, James Baldwin and...